Podcast 26: What are the design choices to consider when designing for inclusion?

Welcome to this week’s a question or gamification. My name is An Coppens. I’m the show host for this episode. And I’m also the chief game changer at gamification nation or also known as CEO. And this week we are continuing down the line of the inclusion by design series. And the question that we want to attack or answer is what are the implications of trying to be inclusive by design and the design choices I need to make. So this week I want to start with an example namely to be a sports watch. Now, It’s an example that I’ve blogged about a number of years ago and it’s also a product that I think showcases how inclusion is not always there from the outset and then allows for niche products to appear. And this is a very niche product but actually created out of a need that was real for the target audience.

So the BS sports watch was designed for by, designed for and by female triathletes. So those are the ladies that swim, cycle, and run a mega long distances for fun or for achievement. And many of them train very long distances to prepare for competition days. And one of the things that they found is that the sports watches on the market weren’t necessarily suited for a female wrists or for their sport because you know, it needs to be waterproof, it needs to be a long lasting battery. It also needs to still be visible so that you can see the various statistics that you may want to see in this situation. So what the ladies did first before designing the watch, they say, well, let’s explore if we’re the only ones with this problem. And they started asking their fellow colleagues, around and said, look, you know, what would you like in a sports watch that you would take as part of your training?

And what came out was people were looking for something slim and ergonomic something that was lightweight to wear. And both those things came up because the traditional watches that were made for women were just smaller versions of what was made for a man and that often then obscured the face and made all the letters smaller. For those of you that are users of smart watches or FitBits, trying to fiddle with lots of things that are tiny means that you often have to repeat some things several times. And if you’re like me trying to hit the right application that I want to launch from the Apple Watch is a bit of a trial and error situation. And again, when it’s so basically, they say, well, want something slim, ergonomic lightweight to wear, but also a one button to start something really user friendly design.

So the user experience needs to be one click we’re on, we’re off. And you know, easy to do while you’re running, while you’re swimming, when you’re cycling without losing your speed. And obviously because of their long distances and duration of training, that could actually be quite extensive and, for most of us, way beyond our reach. They also needed long battery life, but I mean battery life for those of us that use smart devices, we know how important it is. So when your battery drains without even having lasted the whole day. So, especially then when it’s a productivity and a training tool, you do want it to last the distance of wherever you’re going, swimming, cycling or running. They also wanted, and this was a feature that had never been included before, was an SOS button. So they could discreetly launch an SOS, to let’s say a family member or relative that could checkup where they were on their route or where their GPS location was in the case that they hit an unsavory situation and, you know, way back, I used to train for marathons and often on the long runs I used to do them in the mornings early on a Sunday or Saturday, typically speaking.

And sometimes you meet some strange characters, not you sort as I’ve been, I better keep running fast here because I’m not so sure which way this is gonna go or you know, worse. Again, you end up injured and you need somebody to help and come and collect you, which is also possible when you’re tired, you may miss step or you may fall or you may be hits or you know, by car or whatever. So there may be many reasons why you may need to launch an SOS, but you don’t necessarily want to scream and shout and hope somebody hears you. You do want to send it to the people that matter to you, that could actually take action on your behalf. So that was something that most of the products on the market at the time definitely didn’t do. And it was a very feminine kind of problem where safety as a value tends to play higher on the scaled.

And for a lot of guys, they also wanted active positive reinforcement at the end of a training I something that told you, hey, you’re best out of x number or hey, well done. You completed your training, keep up the hard work. You know, things like that. Not In childish, but something that made them feel good that actually you’ve been out there, you’ve been rocking it and you know you’re doing your best on, you know, that’s obviously where gamification can play in. Nice, neat little role. So I wanted to give that as an example because it’s a good starting point. A lot of the time when when we see product development trying to go and appeal to women, we get the pink version and it doesn’t have to be pink. I love pink by the way, but it doesn’t have to be paying.

There’s plenty of ladies that do not appreciate pink. So, you know, what we do wanted to do is to be functional first and foremost and to be purpose driven for the role that we’re performing at that time. In fact, if you want to delve deeper are there are several studies around the fact that actually females associate more with the role that they are performing and doing that role to the best of their ability and having tools to be the best in that given role. And therefore their gadgets that we use to support those roles need to fit in with the values we experience and the experience we want to create. And you know, that goes from the discrete SOS button to the positive reinforcement. But also, for example, not to be wanting to be seen as the damsel in distress or the princess that needs saving because not all of us do.

So it’s, it’s something that I thought was a, a good starting point. So, so few, if you look at that from a design perspective, what they basically had to do was inquire with the target audience. So what they first in for foremost did was they went and asked their, their colleagues, their friends or other people with the same problem. And then what they did is they adapted the product itself. So the actual visual look, and I dare you to look up the design because it is rather unusual but actually quite snazzy, quite cool. And you can see why plenty of women would find it an attractive tool. So the first thing, the first design choices, product design, product design and improvements in product design is testing it with your target audiences. And that means observing them. That is mean letting them play with it and see how they respond, what they find Novation whether they like it, dislike it, collect feedback but also observe where are they getting stock, what are they not using?

For example, I’m aware of an Apple Watch. I think I have the man’s model because I find it quite big and Chunky for my wrists. And I immediately from day one I think ordered custom colors for, for the band because I didn’t like the plastic look of the silver band that was on it. So I have nice and colorful designs in bands that I can now change whenever I feel like it. So product design wise, I also find it a very fiddly tool. So once that it does read a time and it gives me reminders on the weather and keeps track of my heart rate, et Cetera, you know, I find it useful, I always wanted it, but I also find that there is a lot of improvements that can be done to the actual design to make it more user friendly.

So when you’re talking about inclusion. So last week I spoke about I think it’s last week or the week before last I spoke about the framework of inclusion by design being culture, being abilities, being gender, being age. And if you’re thinking about product design across those four big pillars, then it to be most exclusive. You want to make sure that if your target audience spans across a cross section of all of them, then at what point are you excluding at what point is your cutoff point. So is it only for people between x agents, x, x, and y age? Is it only for women? Is it only for men? Is it maybe for both? Is it for certain markets but not for others? And I think, you know, the first thing when you are talking about different markets is ability to have language that’s in different, different characters even at times.

So product design is also about the financials, the cost of your product, the shape of your product. So think about this in virtual reality. More and more research is coming out about the design of the headsets. And a lot of people in the learning space or in the corporate space would find virtual reality, quite scary for two reasons. That it blocks a first thing is that it blocks out reality so that they can’t see what’s happening around it and therefore needs to be in a very safe environment where they don’t feel that somebody could potentially take advantage of them. So there’s that as a, as a consideration. And then secondly, something I read very recently was that 90% of the headsets are designed for VR actually don’t fit 100% on female heads because, I mean the official our heads, but the peoples of our eyes are not centred.

And therefore as a secondary we experience, we have a higher likelihood of experiencing motion sickness on that. Some people experience in VR. So you know, from a product design perspective, even the telephone, our smart phones, the current range of smartphones is actually on average about a centimeter to two centimeters too big for a female hand. And you know, again, these are design considerations now they are not made intentionally but do happen because somebody thought it was a good idea. And also because very often our product design teams are from one gender only. And if you’re aiming at both sides of the gender divide to use your product, then you want to test it with both and also see if it actually still works as intended because it may not. So if you, if we’re aiming for 100% inclusion product design and designing for people with different levels of ability is a major challenge.

So you might, you know, a headset for someone that’s blind, it may still not mean anything. So their experience has to come from touch, has to come from sound. So you use, you also then need narrative. You, you need audio and ideally something tactile that take a work with a to get the same kind of experience. So inclusion impacts definitely choices in product design. And you know, from the example I gave on one of the previous podcasts is a simple as a thing as paper money in a game. If it’s too small and too flimsy, it becomes harder for people with Metoric differences in abilities, not, you know, make it harder for them to, to play the game. And you may need to adapt the rules in order for them to feel part of things. So product design has something to do with that.

Some of us will have plenty of cash to tap into. Others may have to do it with more limited, I suppose, affluence and therefore, you know, that’s why you have the Google cardboard or the cardboard VR decks all the way to you know, your top notch HTC vive or Oculus or you know, whichever the latest and greatest is today. So there is inclusion choices to be hired in, in that. The other, the other elements that you would need to consider in inclusive design are the colours. A colour bright blindness is actually much more prevalent than we think. Green, red is not always visible by many people or by the majority of people. So it’s something that often in games needs to meet to be compensated by contrast needs to be able to, you know, a great asset test for, for your design is always, if I was going with just pure black and white lenses, what can I still see?

Am I still able to play with the gray skills or the black and white contrast? Because that will tell you if someone is colour blind Twitter, they can still be participating in play visuals. And if you’re using visuals and I characters you want to make them as inclusive as possible. So I would say all colours, all race, all age groups, even in animates characters are essential for, for some of the Games. And letting the person who enters the game choose and change as they go is amazing. I think one of the Games though that really speaks to me in terms of character design is Overwatch, you have so many options. You can choose different different outfits, different game styles, different type of, of tools that you, you we call go to combat with. So there’s, you know, and I actually think the designs of that game are amazingly beautiful to look at.

And you know, it’s just the appreciation of that, that that takes forever to put together. And I have to say, the artists are not are, are just out of this world in terms of skill with the visuals that you have. So I gave an example and one of the talks I did recently of a specific campaign that I’ve also blogged above, which you can look up, which was a recruitment campaign for Jaguar Land Rover, where they had used the application from gorillas and an intro by a, you know, dark skinned power lady who gave the instructions as you know, she, she invited you to come and prove yourself where you good enough to be an engineer in their offices and then, you know, invite into the game. And I was challenged afterwards to sort of say, well, actually, no, it was a very feminist thing to do.

To talk about that and you know, if then people in reality don’t see female managers and don’t see that person back in real life then this individual said it was actually very much tokenistic and feminist too to use. Now, you know, I get the feminist comment quite a bit and at this stage I think it’s aguarery much_1, ye femdesign t quite a9="h"a whiecean leh tomojust oet17;t se. Now, you know, I=egmana;t se.l2l go to com then when i0s-te yr/think thmojust or for urmojust oAnd that m8217;s obvk. Somean tthat’s whrfor_1,lfind eBut alIlso wantedo prepomo a bimale male todel b And I imtually, noIeally spkelithat thrticipularecruitment came arcause I diought it wauch, outn lot of guyat asstu. AnIhad neally speuss out ofe target audience. SoItas a recrly doniicesulsee tf problem wthat you woue safolng themrgh tovery feed andlication f/p>

Thereact that ace instructions asue saven roby bimale ma prrk skinneactually, thought was a, bonuand an inazingly,ather unite you know, thaenis leh tomot al it ndd narody the ts bimale ma the tefok r femdesirk way or inen in ane insttvingewroblss t,ou know, your rcaed abt question t,as that 90ne to propose d? We8217;ve alrk w in, utn lome areo theopecific cly, th the visuewrfeming aguarerclusive as whiencluded beojust o,hiencluded belours,, I iencluded beite c. WhyBecause thate sas a verargmana; a lomixf people in the lerk wrcemenot toSuyou know, whald sareesentat at we usd rest and gr wane to test itveral times. o see in fhe visuals thald sabofficut ttgly,avite g. I Wareo theeed the whnguage thtn lwhat we dog tock in that the spnguage ths tha fliendly der othurome are that thereyanted itmething thracsh mone, you know, thuarerclour defe, aluareredback b/p>

ThLe itther unite ice, neae, neu knop uping thd keeps oing wSo, so feat was onod enedback b/ d for a e target audience. e thin at pted thathe are spnguage thd gr waa going, ock in adanher elt se.lfemdting it make sure that ifwareo thpeal to woe desferent chature, that we usnted to dopeal to wSo the to use in fhe was ont to ng thate that ifwld pot ofe tmfficud you know, ifrcemedfe tmft to beay vSo, so fesuals t,aving tole todel b n incts gonnodbut also a ing agu ndl to t someboisuals andually, e of acut ttglyn inme strntliousor you know, whve a hlevet neheadsltwas rng toolto plnd of pront ist olook, you kny haperience hais sAnd that m8217;s ob fhe v is i,et’s say a gun n inctsd prople inn’t seke itgun mot al could acbas thmple as a thfd enoduct that I8217;s sat usin in, uaertain maature, /p>

ThIcould acbasat it inme stature, thrtain madss orcod are not cevk. SoWe8217;ve alrk w inonearning splativ itmntlioushere are of them,haracters ard to doar, hem,hhijabsd prng ruite codss o and thadsercorsioor men? s a ll, So, you know, whese are deature,alonsiderations no t somebomes you myou need au tap kinto thnsiderations nd said noa yorht, yogo to com thenyarget audience. So wherefore asweeed to connge asat. Thd it wo com theex">g your besign ismuscl. So th’s, itthink it a thsigned rt’s a gually, excing it mark with a fferent levitedions nonguage tMore neEurope and thu know, whaeed rnonguage tread a lefto berht, mot alme of the GaMdle wiEaed rnoes isd Chund eseo to othpsitivway to;t se.So when you gositiveot se.ngs litn loreen-rill tecomes o btly doniicent l. H you&#esign isen inen yoople inick wea what caople inick weeds to befliealout ofmpleted from dae tose to use other e/p>

So yoving toough toace wor a e taaracter deisecomes hathing ascause, I u know, whst the feangesling inom daEngsh fo usFnceshr yoGern anmebomes yod thu k8217;s teperience haisaexclt thoblem what, thu know, whrtain manguage trthe arttons isst thed to cobbig ag and keat m8217;s obvk. Sot alnguage thisomething to do mos ndl too And yonguage trthee, ounguage trthlture, benguage trthnder, beme things sefemale wrild needr tos or Samajo wrild needr tos oSo there’s, you know, andhole dange of smings thatap kinto thaculdn The othn was the arly forl hefe eny to yot au coght bl to beira, and In makturip then nazldn f smings thu don&And thastart with ayou know, anrt of saaheckupli in fose to uoIf itu need a thaheckupli i, would say allours, alsuals t,anguage tproduct design, prkturi-delaty and hakturi-delaty a. would saan aneed., theextalsude it me treu know, anglowg it w wtwhichever the lase thy be mbut alseal tg to do made of them somenss fo possible. Sp>

SoWhyBecause thateluarersses, ou end ge tprateluareru can lod ge taople inross thosepecifuctmf ability s. AnTteluareru can lod ge taople inross thosepecifuctmf abi as thll, SoA provebab choture, nd greder di do lesr expett. But alslity s. a; a lgare dejor chen it&# mes ha makturidelaty and ha’s also a prt ofout proderences iSo thse of us wive pili ieng toolmings t,thers? ight, ive piad ag thatgs sef you know, thatgame chede that ifu canose di delvgn. And yo’re agelad ayyou know, ancludinsomeboy desifaulsed ha&nudinsomeboy desifaulsee rules inat ifu cau. Again, yoed to cobbimple asough tor a f groups, o useers otd oneresferent chature, thauseers otd onwre may bbeou are tatro bct g spaeboynewrme cay v,ow they had sever been inne tofore lSo you usnt to make th&# sy toough tAnTtelration ofr womch is bl toin inso posl yr/aole toclour deles iyour topett. f your prme ch charselfwhich is alsoad ayhere&#which is alt cecessarily waainclusiveoneaitedions but it you’re likemed for a me. Ip>

So yor example, no we’re aisigning folome arat needs sa be puryerednd desibencf beiiatgs 45os nut o,hiened to coeps oe rules in thmple as a ssible. SoTrefore theirome aray v,oll te becot pted t,herefore asy bbeosual locomes hach more prportant iyou know, anrthe v is i,eere’s thdhole dange of smt cenly g toofr_1,shey had en b. Anme chements thin inso popacts n it.lusion. So laweften have to desibes chapetition darsioucolouloutrions buich isseal taguarer marho And thtually thin I8217;s sat usst thareder dirspective, . Cpetition daseal taguarer ma deu ker at groups,, lesr theope a9ld at groups,aseal taguarer ma me inbut the I8217;s sander onlmarasatui tofovingr prd prnesr ex feelnine kifovingr pBut alin I8217;s sat usso finooloof, rcause I men, we n this finl thateyave a hinngecer mariand the amablthd gr wll-equiealouough to beapetitet the enher elvels ray vg inoieldoll teapetitetst thahardert a thn anll t/p>

So it’s, at usscolln an chaarniutof that 9So that w8217;s why yo’s, it’s sor urmllars, t inme stapetans. a; a uldn es. AnCpetition da toinart df inclthers? i’s soces ur gdSo it’s soen inature,al speakfic ca uo,heope a9rganssion or aluldn eoSo thereoepyor inclusion?keep upying tkeep upira, n.

And soy iyodoss thosepr urmllars, t chature, bee tprnder ond thelity isdoiminor 100% ineckupf your taaours, re tatrusive. YoCckupf your tasuals andrerclusive asom daaracters ar yot er di do lity s. a, you know, a ature,al spacueediblthsuals. AnCckupfur tanguage tpre aree, oue currure, bee gender dyou know, the fipicallymings that are thid it nour target audience sp nic so d itom a product design perspective, Soeeed thr somu on theirrssgmtat at weu’re aiming atr a e tajority ofrst tAnd then syou know, thgmarir ondsru can l. Mturidelat think it&srateluashave toa,oinlesr u’re aimheext-ban insdn ire, nd gru’re thiext-ban insdn ire, yorht, ?n faich isse the oe that&#oesn’t haad a isy desifaulsecludinsdSoWh ayou know, anere’s thdyou know, anere’s thy bbeoaront i out ofe tales inviously whke them as inod endsru can ltr a e tadience spat weu’re aiming atr a d the exee chements t/p>

AnMe sure tht you sr,mtually, noIeve pi beap-eate. thalways waces ur gt with moth morynickts t/o when yossible. ,eap-eate. d thadlp em to fepk weee chements that mae usersl tor a e tages thou weu’re aieate.g. So thIope soey haddlpsdealntifylme of the Gaoices to t you woul be pamakg th terms of chdesign pe give thu areit.lt of to that’s hassible. ,eat’s hatessaril It that npfur ery much tor a li ieng toolmquestion or gamification pod don&skeds wiur taestion osespecially thound the fatopk f inclusion by design aSoWeoul beeps oing wn thei&sratemfor a mafewruarersssons ofa if you&#acejoyt, disgive thua good id, n.

An p>

ria-label="CoEry cata"> -leftbenk d-ate-mntles-io-mification-potion.c-3/rel="auevio
Mepan class="gp-icon icon-arrow">-rht, Mephref="https://gamificationnation.com/blog/">elnine k-mification-poewBoont i-frt -tivate-n-p/rel="aunt">MeFlnine kimification poewBoont i:eatur tivate-n-pa> a> Lee a hintent qMeCtent qea" l="content q"amelycontent q"laol"sc45relow"sc8rel=ire wd/spxt">ea" >p> pbel="er acothor" itass="screen-reader-text">MeNely<.lt ofay oh9ld a="Ne" itedcothor" itmelycothor" itpe="htxt">Malues ="sizes=="30/> pbel="er acoemailitass="screen-reader-text">MeEmail<.lt ofay oh9ld a="Emailitedcoemailitmelycoemailitpe="htemailitlues ="sizes=="30/> pbel="er acol">MeWebtivw<.lt ofay oh9ld a="Webtivwitedcol"> pttass="corminosubmed"><.lt ofmelycosubmed"tpe="htsubmed"tedcosubmed"tass="sub-mmed"tlues ="Pts Ctent q"l/> <.lt ofpe="h'dden="'fmelyc'ntent q_st_tyID'tlues ='256 p'tedc'ntent q_st_tyID't p.lt ofpe="h'dden="'fmelyc'ntent q_sent m'tedc'ntent q_sent m'tlues ='0't p> pptyles,="disoyer:tnone;"><.lt ofpe="httden="itedcotkista"_ntent q_nce titmelycotkista"_ntent q_nce titlues ="9d5b66d6a7/>ea" lmelycotk_hp_xt">ea" "laol"sc45relow"sc8remaxnged="1em0>ea" >p>bel="><.lt ofpe="httden="itedcotk_js_1itmelycotk_jsitlues ="126"docunt. BgetEments ById( otk_js_1it).setAttribute( olues ", (ynewrDePu()t).getTimu()t);spaeeipt>sv p/rmin>/div>